A Taxing Matter for the New Year

fireworks Cole Vassiliou
Image courtesy of Cole Vassiliou

HAPPY NEW YEAR!  

Here we are and here is the first blog of the new year … and I have to bring up the spectre of  TAX.

Do you think Amazon* should pay their taxes? Of course you do! Well, the EU have closed a loophole that Amazon and others were using to undercharge, and so underpay, the VAT on some goods – ebooks in particular. As from January 1st Amazon must charge the VAT rate for ebooks in the member state the ebook is bought in.

Let me explain… Amazon has its EU servers in Luxembourg – and has been charging the customer only 3% VAT on ebooks as this is the ebook VAT rate in Luxembourg. *(As do Apple, Google and Nook so this applies to them too)  They reasoned that they were charging the VAT rate where the commodity (ebook) was Sold –  ie by Amazon/Apple/Nook etc  in Luxembourg.

Now that it has been ‘clarified’ Amazon has added on the VAT rate applied in each of the member states to the price of the ebooks as listed.

OK? Umm?

Well, this means that all the ebooks on Amazon sold in the UK will now have 17% added to them to bring them up to OUR 20% VAT rate for ebooks. (I presume this is happening on Nook and Apple too but do not have the personal evidence to draw on)  Now this does not only apply to Amazon, so prices will have risen across the board and even if it is sold by a non-VAT registered outfit (earning too little to deal with VAT) it will still have to be price-matched with Amazon if they want their books to be available there as well.  So it will mean a price increase, unless the author/publisher can absorb the increase.

If you are like many of the large publishing houses who have set their ebook price as almost as high as their paperback price – perhaps you could. However, if you are like most individual Authors, or are published by a small publisher (an Indie Publisher), then you have usually set your ebook at a reasonable level, much lower than the paper-back price, that gives you a reasonable return and the customer a great deal.  So the individuals and the Indie publishers won’t be able to absorb the VAT increase and as we are all used to ebook prices being very reasonable, this may hurt a bit!

skos front for ppI just  wonder why ebooks aren’t rated the same as paper-books. Consider this – books – paper-books – are zero rated in the UK. Why do you think that is? Think of the other things that are zero rated. Food (excluding sweets, cakes etc) Water, Children’s Clothes and Footwear,  certain Safety Equipment, Power, Ship-building, Helicopter and Aircraft making ….  all thing important to the health, well-being education or protection of the people.red one

However, it transpires, that ebooks are designated as a ‘supply of a service’ not as a book.  This seems very odd to me, the CONTENT of an ebook is the same as the content of the paper-book. Perhaps it is because if you buy an ebook from Amazon they have the ability to ‘take it back’ if need be – and this makes it a ‘supply’ rather than an ‘item’. Even if this is so then not every country sees it this way.

It seems that it is only Germany and the UK that treat ebooks to the full VAT rate. In Luxembourg it is 3% , France it is currently 5.5% , Italy is reducing their ebooks from the standard rate down to 4% and Malta likewise but down to 5% – the latter two to match their paper-book rate.

InAngel Bug Cover Ultimate the UK they say they have no intention of lowering the ebook VAT rate and warn that ‘harmonisation’ may end up with printed books having to pay the lower rate too (instead of zero) A warning that has upset the publishing houses and one that would also upset readers.

There doesn’t seem to have been much about this in the general press which is why I’ve chosen to write it in this blog. At least now, if you go to buy an ebook in a series and the price has ‘jumped up’ from the last one you bought, you’ll know why – and it will probably be by 17%.

Now, we only have to hope that Amazon/ Apple/ Nook PAY those taxes 🙂

Had you heard about this change in VAT rates for ebooks?

Do you think all books (electronic or paper) should be zero rated as being ‘good for us’?

Do let me know what you think – you know I love to hear from you

6 thoughts on “A Taxing Matter for the New Year”

  1. I hadn’t heard about this. How very sneaky to slip this sort of thing under the radar, so to speak, hoping that it will go unnoticed by the vast majority of book buyers – which it probably will 🙁

    The thing is that 17% extra is such a relatively large amount to add on – making buyers more selective, making more paperwork and less profit for sellers, making less profit for authors….I was going to say that the only winner in this scenario would be the tax man (and possibly accountants with an increase in workload) but actually, as in so many other instances, the unintended consequences at the end of the day might be less tax revenue because of decreasing sales.

    We are after all, I think, still in a financial recession (or is that depression?!) on the bright side, this is an election year, maybe this subject will get more press coverage and make people aware and politicians wary…..

  2. Hi Christine,
    It was reported in the media at end of 2013 when the ruling was made … and they gave until the end of 2014 to implement it. So I guess it seemed like old news to the media. The only recent media coverage has been in the book-seller / ebook retailer related press (online generally)

    I just didn’t want people who have bought one or two of my books before the New Year coming back to buy another and thinking I’d hiked the prices willy-nilly – especially when it was done automatically by Amazon. Still, though we couldn’t absorb the rise, at less than a third of the paperback list price I think we still offer a good deal for our ebook readers!

  3. To be honest, I’ve never thought about VAT/Tax when thinking of books or ebooks – maybe I had not paid enough attention to the issue.
    It is good that you brought this up and raised attention to it – I don’t think many people realize this. I find it really interesting and got me thinking about what else is taxed or exempt and I don’t know it

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

error

Enjoyed this blog? Please share :)